Thursday, September 20, 2012

Porter apologizes for missed call

It won't change anything -- certainly not the outcome of the game -- but umpire Alan Porter did apologize to Davey Johnson and admit to blowing a crucial call at the plate during the fourth inning last night at Nationals Park.

Johnson said the apology came later during the game, with Porter admitting he should not have credited the Dodgers with a run on a play in which the third out was recorded at third base before another runner crossed the plate.

"He said, 'I'm sorry I messed it up,'" Johnson revealed this afternoon. "They're good guys. I don't have a beef with them. But when you miss one, get help. He got help, and they still didn't get it right."

On the play in question, Porter counted a run scored by Matt Kemp even though the Dodgers slugger was 10 feet short of the plate when teammate Adrian Gonzalez was tagged out near third base by Ryan Zimmerman.

Porter didn't make any call until Los Angeles manager Don Mattingly came out of the dugout to raise the question, at which point the entire umpiring crew huddled to discuss the play. Porter then signaled the run should count, bringing Johnson out of his dugout to argue.

"To err is human," Johnson said. "It can happen. I knew that he didn't see it, because if he saw it, the first move is: boom [pointing down], the run counts. That's what they do. And he didn't do it, and I thought: 'That's great, because he saw it.' And then Mattingly comes out, and he said: 'OK, the run scored.' So I know he didn't see it. But when they met I thought somebody would get it right."

Crew chief Mike Winters declined to speak to a pool reporter about the call after the game, which wound up a 7-6 Dodgers win, with the mistaken run proving the margin of victory.

This was the second obviously missed call to hurt the Nationals in a span of four days. On Saturday in Atlanta, umpire Marvin Hudson ruled Adam LaRoche's foot off first base on a routine play, even though replays clearly showed LaRoche making contact with the bag. The Braves' next batter, Jason Heyward, clubbed a home run to set his team on its way to a 5-4 victory.

Neither play was reviewable by Major League Baseball's current system, nor could the Nationals file a formal protest in either case (because out-safe decisions are considered judgment calls, not a rules interpretation).

Johnson isn't a proponent of expanded replay that requires umpires to leave the field and review controversial plays on a monitor, but he would support a system that added an "eye-in-the-sky" official who could overrule umpires from the press box after seeing a mistake on TV replays.

"I'm not a big proponent of going to the video room all the time," Johnson said. "The game's long enough. Maybe somebody up top in the pressbox with you guys, looking down with all the video right there, they could just do a flash card or something. ... Instead of running off the field and then looking, have one of them representatives up there up top."


Manassas Nats' Fan said...

What made Porter think Kemp crossed in time. That is what I have yet to figure out.

natsfan1a said...

Thanks, Mark. And I appreciate the apology.

Scooter said...

MNF, if I hadn't watched Kemp, I would have guessed he scored, because a) he had a good lead off third, b) he's much faster than Gonzalez, and c) Gonzalez slowed up a bit to avoid the tag.

In fact, I didn't watch Kemp, so I wasn't surprised that they said he scored. Didn't see a replay till I got home.

Not excusing. But you wanted to know why he thought he scored. I think that's why.

Scooter said...

What I mean to say is, if I just had no idea whether Kemp scored (which I didn't), because I wasn't paying attention (which I wasn't), and so I had to make an educated guess (which I did), I would have made the same guess that the umpire made.

He, of course, shouldn't have to guess, but we already established that.

Manassas Nats' Fan said...

On first viewinh I saw him jogging and when Zim tagged AGon he was leaaving the screen so it was obvious he was not close and I knew that long before I saw a replay.

When did he talk to Johnson? During game? He left field to see it?

Scooter said...

I don't know what to tell you, MNF. Clearly the man should be shot. Okay?

Post a Comment